From digest.v6.n866 Thu Jul 10 08:34:56 1997
From: Ephraim Fithian <fithian_at_epix.net>
Date: Wed, 9 Jul 1997 20:53:30 +0100
Subject: <E30> Water Pump Replacement Fun
My daughter's 85 318i 5-speed 4-door began leaking antifreeze from the
water pump after all of the other leaks were fixed.
First step was to find a price on a rebuilt water pump. Some of the Roundel
advertisers listed the part for about $24. These are made in some unknown
country and are of questionable origin.
Bimmer Parts wanted $66 for a BMW rebuilt unit that I decided to go with.
BMW store in Cincinnati was about same price. Unit lists for $79 in the BMW
Price List Book.
Not wanting to get my hands dirty. I checked the local BMW dealers and an
independent shop. The dealer in Doylestown, PA, said they wouldn't be able
to look at the car for 2 weeks due to the holiday (July 4). The dealer in
West Chester, PA, said, "Bring it in this afternoon. We'll get it done
today." They wanted $102 for the rebuilt pump and 1.8 hours of labor. The
independent shop in King of Prussia, PA wanted 2.5 hours of labor plus an
unstated amount for the pump itself.
Since it looked like it was going to cost my money-deficient daughter about
$300, I decided to do it for her. Big mistake!
Bimmer Parts is about 30 minutes away, so I gave them a day to get it and
drove down to pick it up. They even took back a pair of 318i brake drums
(remember those?) that I had purchased from them about 2 years ago. The
return paid for the pump and a new air filter with some $6 left in change.
Fortunately, I had the E30 factory manual available, although the
instructions were rather short, sort of like, "Use special tool
X2R34Z-7......" So I pretty much ignored the instructions and just dived
in. Since I don't have special tools, I figured it might take a little
longer. 4 hours later, having finally figured out all of the little things
that all BMW mechanics know, the pump was installed.
I filled it up with antifreeze and started her up. Everything was perfect,
except for this stream of antifreeze that was flowing from the bottom of
the water pump onto my garage floor. The gasket had a crimp in it.
The second installation only took about, let's see, 1.8 hours, since I know
knew all of the shortcuts. The gasket is now encased in permatex and no
Moral of the story - pay the man to do it or plan on spending 4 times as
much time doing it.
Ephraim Fithian <fithian_at_epix.net> http://www.epix.net/~fithian
92 E36 325i 5-speed 84k, 97 E39 528i 5-speed 24k.
Previous 78 530i 4-speed 192k, 84 318i 5-speed 18k,
85 535i 5-speed 117k, 95 530i 5-speed 24k.
BMWCCA, NMA, Macintosh, Eastern PA.
[ Help ]